THE O.J. Simpson test is just one representation of exactly just just how domestic physical physical violence haunts society that is american. Is “Gone with all the Wind” another? Especially, did Rhett Butler rape or, less offensively, ravish Scarlett O’Hara?
The debate started a years that are few in educational journals therefore the lecture hallway between two feminist philosophers — one of these Christina Hoff Sommers, who may have since outraged many feminists together with her book “Who Stole Feminism? exactly How ladies Betrayed Women,” posted a year ago. The argument inside her guide — that feminism is dominated by people who look for to persuade the general public that American ladies “are perhaps maybe maybe not the free animals we think our company is” — is foreshadowed within the dispute over Margaret Mitchell’s Civil War saga.
Just in case you missed it, the debate has resurfaced once again. Listed here are excerpts. TOM KUNTZ
From a message offered fall that is last the American Enterprise Institute by Ms. Sommers, a co-employee teacher of philosophy at Clark University in Worcester, Mass., and reprinted in the present problem of The United states Enterprise:
Until 1989, I became a educational feminist in good standing. My essays were contained in feminine anthologies. I happened to be invited to conferences that are feminist. My courses had been cross-listed with ladies’ Studies. We ran afoul regarding the establishment that is feminist We published an essay into the Chronicle of Higher Education that said something politically wrong concerning the famous staircase scene in “Gone aided by the Wind.”
“a lot of women,” we wrote, “continue steadily to benefit from the sight of Rhett Butler Scarlett that is carrying O’Hara the stairs in a fate undreamt of in feminist philosophy.”
We designed that to be both lighthearted and a severe caution that feminist theorists had been away from touch with females. (more…)